All Grain Brewing - Is It That Much Better and Can I Do It Without Spending Too Much?

There are two recurring questions that come up inup to you, and may be dependant on what you have
respect of all-grain home brewing. The first isaround the house or what you are prepared to buy.
whether the product is that much better. TheBut remember, if you are trialling all grain, it is better
second is whether there is a way to do it withoutto try it without buying anything so that you can
spending too much. The answer to both questions issave you money for when you decide all grain is for
a resounding yes.you. If its not, then you have not spent a cent.
There is no doubt that the beer that is producedThere are two broad categories of brewing for the
using all grain is better than an extract or kit beer.beginner, full volume and simple sparging. I'll explain
Yes you can make good beer using extract and kits.both below.
You may even make a great beer. But, the proof isFull Volume
in the tasting. Get a beer brewed using extract andThis is the easiest method possible. Get your mash
compare it to one brewed using all grain and you willtun and mix up the crushed grain with warm water.
immediately tell the difference. All grain beer isThe amount of water needed here will be the final
fresher and fuller in flavour. Extract has a tendencyvolume desired plus a litre for each kilogram of grain
to have a twang regardless of how well the otherin the mash. Leave it for an hour to convert the
important factors of yeast use and temperaturestarch to sugar and either drain off the liquid or take
control are managed.out the solids (grain). How you do this depends on
Is all grain that much better to justify the expenseyour equipment.
of going all grain, both in dollars spent as well as timeIf you are mashing in an esky it should be easy
spent? For some it is, and for others it isn't. It comesenough to drain the liquid off into a big pot. If you
down to why you brew and how much you enjoyare mashing in an esky and draining to a pot, some
the act of brewing itself. If you are not sure there isof the simple sparging methods may be better, but
that middle ground of partial brewing. All grain brewingfull volume is very easy.
to comprise half the final volume and topping up withIf you are mashing in your big pot, which may be
extract. For a lot of people this is the start of theyour boiling pot it can be a bit more difficult.
slippery slope. People buy equipment to do partials,However, there is a nice little way of doing this
mashing say 2-3 kg of grain and topping up with a kiteasily, it is know as brewing in a bag and it may be a
to make 23 litres. Then within a couple of monthsworthwhile purchase. Simply you buy or make a bag
more money has been spent and it's all grain brewingout of a material that allows liquid to easily pass
from then on.through and the crushed grain remain in the bag. The
So how can we bypass that partial stage and startbag goes in the pot of water and you add the grain
on the full mash brewing straight away to decideto the bag. When the mash is done, give it a
whether the expense is worth it? It is quite easy.vigorous stir and take the bag out, give it a squeeze
There is a good chance the equipment you need isand you are done. So what material is best? Sheer
already in your house and if not it could be prettycurtain material made of polyester works a treat.
easily purchased for very little.Muslin could also work but because this tends to be
So what are our steps broadly? Firstly the mash. Thiscotton it will easily rot over time if you are not
is where we add water to the grain at a specifiedcareful.
temp (usually around 66 degrees) to convert theThe benefit of full volume is you don't need any
starch in the grain to sugar. Secondly, drain or sparge.other equipment.
This is to separate the liquid from the solids. Thirdly,Simple sparging
the boil. We boil the liquid for at least an hour. It is atThere are of course a few options here. Firstly, there
this stage we add the hops which add bitterness andis the batch sparge and secondly the simple sparge.
flavour to the beer. Finally we chill, ferment and waitIf you are using an esky and big pot for your
patiently to bottle it and drink it.brewing you can batch sparge. Drain off the liquid
The first step of mashing requires something tofrom your mash to your big pot. Then add hot water
mash in. For some this is an old esky (or a new one)(say 80 degrees) to the grains, stir, leave it for ten
and for others it is a large pot. The size of this 'mashminutes and drain off. This can be done once twice
tun' needs to be at least the size of your desiredor three times. Twice is probably best. But you'll need
final volume of beer but it may need to be bigger ifto have other pots to heat the water for sparging
you are doing full volume mashing discussed below.up. It can get a little tricky.
For a lot of people the size of a batch would be theIf you are using a big pot as your mash tun you
standard kit size of around 23 litres. For those usingneed to be able to separate the liquids from the
kegs it might be 19 litres. But, all grain brewing is notsolids. If you don't want to use the brew in a bag
limited by the size of the can of extract. You canoption it can become a little bit of a juggling act. You'll
make the brew size anything you want. If you haveneed other pots and containers and you'll need
a 20 litre pot, perhaps do 16 litre batches. It's still acolanders and strainers. Sit a colander on top of
good quantity of beer and if you enjoy it you cananother container and ladle out the grains and liquid
brew more often. So, if you have an esky and ainto the container. You may need a lot of pots and
larger pot you can trial all-grain using those twocontainers depending on your volume. Then run the
pieces of equipment and adjust your brew size tosparge water over the drained grains to 'wash' off
suit what you have. Do a couple and then buy whatmore of the sugars. This works and has been done
you want, if you want, to make bigger batches or toby many a new brewer but there are easier ways.
set up you set up a little better.If you have an esky and you have a larger pot you
Now, once we have worked out our batch size andcan start brewing all grain today for free. Otherwise
our base equipment we need to look at the differentyou can start brewing all grain for very little. There is
ways we can go about brewing and work out whichno need to buy masses of equipment. Best to leave
equipment we need from there. The choice is entirelythat until you have decided it is for you.